Always Jiang Jianxiang of city deputy mayor after front courtyard careful (getting on a car) be intercepted to interview by media. Tao Ran of capital times reporter is photographed
Tang Hui appeals to always state city service teachs appoint case 2 careful are sessional yesterday, through the intense debate of 4 hours, collegiate bench classics rests front courtyard appraise sth through discussion thinks this proposal is radical the fact has made a thorough investigation of, the judge announces choose period is adjudged finally.
Acting lawyer Xu Liping of Tang Hui and riverside mark are strong (Small gain)In front courtyard careful, point to continuously always state city service teachs appoint teach to Tawatch casesng Hui's fatigue break the law. Always state city service teachs appoint director Jiang Jianxiang appears in court should appeal to, in be stated finally Xiang Tanghui expresses regret.
Lei Jun of capital times reporter
Fatigue teachs Tang Hui is to break the law undeserved still
Yesterday morning at 8 o'clock half, front courtyard careful is punctual undertake, the be a visitor at a meeting of about 200 people that includes media reporter, National People's Congress to be represented inside whole process.
Both sides is stated respectively petition for appeal and rejoin after the opinion, judicial general the focal reduce of this case controversy 3: Always state city service teachs appoint do not grant to compensate for to Tang Hui whether to have fact and legal basis; Always state city service teachs appoint if ought to assume liability to pay compensation, what are the means that its compensate for, limits and amount; First instance adjudicates whether cognizance fact is clear. Because bilateral difference is vast, focus of both sides dominating debate all is in actually centrally " always state city service teachs appoint carry out fatigue teaching to whether break the law to Tang Hui " on.
Last year on August 2, always state city service teachs appoint the decision that makes fatigue teach a year 6 months to Tang Hui. On August 10, hunan Province fatigue teachs appoint " administration reconsiders decision book " cancel should decide, think Tang Hui disturbs badly for many times national office and society are normal order, answer to assume corresponding legal responsibility lawfully, but " have admonitory, education lawfully to Tang Hui more appropriate, need not grant to work breeding " .
Tang Hui's counsel for the defence thinks, above cancel decision is the direct basis that to Tang Hui fatigue teachs illegal sex. Tang Hui appebrass faucetals for help is to have no alternative of the redress an injustice below lift, do not break the law, according to the country " the letter visits byelaw " , "Education and admonitory what all eliminate fatigue teaching is applicable " .
Always state city service teachs appoint insist to think, fatigue teachs a decision by cancel as a result of,be " specific administration misconduct " and the humanitarian consideration that stems from pair of Tang Hui's daughters, do not break the law, reason does not need to compensate for. This says to suffer the doubt of lawyer of Tang Hui representative, because cancel decides of the basis is " administration reconsiders a law " the 28th the first (3) , this include 5 kinds of state, "Specific administration action is apparently improper " just among them one of, still include " surmount or misuse of authority " etc. Xu Liping's lawyer points out, even if is " apparently undeserved " , the other side also should be compensated for.
Always the city admits to ever raised 3 requirements " money of a place of strategic importance "
In process of front courtyard careful, tang Hui rejects to mediate again. The Tang Hui before this is mentioned, arrived 31 days on May 29 this year, always state city service teachs appoint once accompanied in Hunan Province tall courtyard fall to be mediated with its, but abortive.
Pu Zhijiang's lawyer is in qualitative card phase to ask a question of the other side, the requirement mediates plan to make a specification at this point. Always state city service the most popular north face shirtsteachs appoint admit, want Tang Hui to agree only " recall appeal " " reflective problem wants lawfully reasonable " " intercessory end a case " wait for 3 conditions, this appoint agrees with Tang Hui's compensation to request at that time, be willing to coordinate local government to give its 100 thousand yuan of relief moneys.
Pu Zhijiang and Xu Liping point out at once, if not be to realize oneself fatigue teachs a decision the mistake, always does state city service teach appoint the litigant request that below the circumstance that why can you win the lawsuit in first instance Tang Hui promises? City service teachs Dan Yongzhou appoint respect criterion explanation says, promising mediation is the esteem of tall to the province courtyard, domestic situation of Tang Hui also lets them be willing to lower attitude to mediate end a casethe most popular selling norton internet antivirus, "Although Tang Hui has very much illegal action, but she is after all always a of the city common masses, we should offer more attention, care " .
Tang Hui is excited and tongue-tied tell about appeal for help to be made stop
In judicial cognizance process, tang Hui for many times the point of view that rage expresses him, count because of,spend the mood hard be pacified and cannot make a speech. The presiding judge gives Tang Hui sufficient respect, suggest she rests and wait several minutes, when Dan Tanghui asks to tell about the course that he appeals for help and experience, because of have nothing to do with this case and check. She expresses in stating finally: "I ask to save tall courtyard to be able to give me justice, hope my last hope is not undone. Hope my last hope is not undone..
Yesterday, always director of state city deputy mayor, public security holds fatigue concurrently to teach appoint director Jiang Jianxiang appears in court personally should appeal to, he holds to will lengthy final statement to read aloud. Jiang Jianxiang says, regard a country as the executive authority, making fatigue teach a decision to Tang Hui is lawfully place of administration, duty; And as the citizen, no matter be expression appeals to,uphold the right, must seek the settlement of the problem inside legal frame.
Jiang Jianxiang says, fatigue teaching decision is taught by province fatigue appoint cancel, demonstrative one's own side considers the special situation of Tang Hui's daughter not, humanitarian care is inadequate, "Express regret here " . He is mentioned, execute the law in practice, affection, manage, law often interweaves each other and mediate hard. The experience of Tang Hui's daughter is worth to sympathize with, the indemnity that she puts forward is not big also, completely OK " one compensate " , it is public opinion, OK also to can appease a network already so clear up the pressure of each respect, but " law is not trifling matter, national compensation cannot do it arbitrarily " , be forced to make this hardship decide.
Whether to compensate for controversy to still need to examine greatly
In the morning after the intense debate of 4 hours, the presiding judge announces to rest front courtyard rests.
He Tanghui of Xu Liping's lawyer all figures before this, in view of the processing means of this Hunan Province tall courtyard and attitude, this case can be adjudged very likely on the court. However, firm at 1 o'clock afternoon open a court session, after the presiding judge is summed up simply, announce to rest front courtyard, choose period is adjudged. "Collegiate bench rests front courtyard had appraise sth through discussion, think this proposal is radicathe most popular watch casesl the fact has made a i want modern dining chairsthorough investigation of, but both sides is great controversy, the fact that collegiate bench still needs to join entire case undertakes be checkupped integratedly. The fact thfree watch caseat collegiate bench still needs to join entire case undertakes be checkupped integratedly..
To this result, media reporter and Tang Hui Fang Jun to one's great diappointment. Xu Liping's lawyer introduces, the basis tries the regulation of deadline, this case is the latest should on July 16 careful writtens guarantee. Pu Zhijiang's lawyer expresses, both sides is in because of putting originally tremendous controversy just appeals, since the fact is clear, the judge all can be adjudged directly usually, but such eventuate Tang Hui added a lot of variable.
But two counsel for the defence all give higher opinion to 2 careful, state pair of results are confidthe best spring poolent, "More open, collegiate bench gave everybody a lot of spaces " .
Outside □ front courtyard
Deputy mayor
Ever 3 times refus approves fatigue to teach Tang Hui
2 careful were not adjudged, tangnorton internet antivirus Hui incident will still ferment continuously. Jiang Jianxiang is in cease when the reporter is being accepted to interview during front courtyard, express, no matter lawsuit is defeated to perhaps win, always state city service teachs appoint will continue to coordinate local government, give Tang Hui more consideration and take care of.
Always state city service teachs appoint the illegal fact that to Tang Hui fatigue teachs a decision, all be a few months and even happen 9 years ago, and detain Tang Hui below abrupt case send fatigue in police station to teach. Jiang Jianxiang says, a year before fatigue teachs Tang Hui many in, always substation of 0 hill area public security ever reported 3 times education of pair of Tang Hui work, oneself all do not have approval.
Tang Hui
Lose lawsuit general appeal or appeal for help
Walk out of judicial Tang Hui's bemused sturdy the earth's surface to show, if lawsuit was defeated, oneself are met certainly appeal, "Hunan cannot find fairness, go to Beijing. " she still says, the thing that fatigue teachs comes to an end, but nonfeasance of the policeman in daughter case, be suspected of tipping off information, offer perjured wait for a problem to still did not get settlement, "The board of inquiry in the province checks 8 months, did not give me the result all the time. " Tang Hui says, she plans to write to inform against a letter to be sent toward concerned branch to erupt simultaneously to the net at this point, if do not have a result, be forced to continue to appeal for help.
That is to say, no matter lawsuit is defeated,win, tang Hui returns the old road that appeal for help probably. "Do not have method, I can choose my way only. " Tang Hui says helplessly.
Lawyer
Of Tang Hui hold to " had won "
Acting lawyer Pu Zhijiang of Tang Hui says, the key of Tang Hui case is not case itself, no matter be defeated or win, tang Hui holds to mediumly in this process " had won " , "3 less important fatigue teach Tang Hui in front, she serves as party complete not know the inside story, the specification was not passed at all any investigation obtains evidence program " .
In process of front courtyard careful, pu Zhijiang ever taught a system ask a question with respect to fatigue for many times, one's words is wonderful. Pu Zhijiang summary says, tang Hui insisted to win a society to respect with what serve as a mother, tang Hui incident is the be caused by of keep long in stock of not reasonable condition with old society, do not solve casuse and effect, the crime that cannot dissolve keep long in stock is angry. "No matter the fatigue of Chongqing teachs a case, still be Tang Hui case, will discuss fatigue to teach a system to keep useless process afresh in China in, leave the brushstroke of thick Mo Chongcai. Before perhaps this case can become revocmodern dining chairsatory fatigue to teach the last case, so we are to using our action to write the history. So we are to using our action to write the history..
No comments:
Post a Comment