Tang Hui is surrounded all round by the reporter.
Changsha of exercitation reporter Ding Zhuang reports Zhou Hui of reporter of learn on job
On July 2, changsha is hot and dry.
Have " appeal for help mom " the Hunan Province of Tang Hui appeal that say always state cbrass faucet aerator ity service teachs appoint one case, 2 careful in Hunan Province open a court session of senior people court is tried. Front courtyard careful lasted 4 many hours. Final, hunan Province tall courtyard announces choose period is adjudged.
The front courtyard careful that day opens 50 media banquet to give journalist audit front courtyard try especially. Our newspaper reporter also shows up audit. Focus of front courtyard careful still focusing is in always state city service teachs appoint teach the controversy that whether breaks the law to go up to Tang Hui's fatigue. On front courtyard, always long service holding city concurrently teachs public security bureau of state city deputy mayor, city appoint director Jiang Jianxiang, with " humanitarian care is inadequate " for, apologize to Tang Hui first.
City service teachs Dan Yongzhou appoint insist to think from beginning to end, tang Hui appeals for help illegally for many times, fatigue teachs appoint undertake to its fatigue teachs lawfully, do not have undeserved. "Tang Hui breaks the law for many times, I sign (approval fatigue teachs) , also do not have method. " Jiang Jianxiang expresses when our newspaper reporter is accepted to interview after front courtyard careful ends.
After front courtyard careful, tang Hui expresses to our newspaper reporter, if tall courtyard cannot give her a judicial court decision, she can continue with always state city service teachs appoint think " illegal " pattern appeals for help to Beijing.
2012, tang Hui is forced to walk the street because of 11 years old of daughters case appeal for help, by always state city service teachs appoint fatigue teaching, in public opinion attention falls after, always state city service teachs appoint with " humanitarian consideration " for release its. Tang Hui shape is accused later always state city service teachs appoint, was in April this year always court of state city intermediate people loses a lawsuit.
watch case Fatigue teachs appoint: Apology but do not break the law
Did not arrive at 8 o'clock in the morning on July 2, large quantities of crowds gather at the door Hunan Province tall courtyard, more than 50 reporter includes in the center.
Hunan Province of Tang Hui appeal always state city service teachs appoint case 2 careful, be about to try here. With was in April always the first instance of city quadrangle is same, one of typical cases that are regarded as fatigue to teach a system abolish eve by the outside and get attention fully. Add this Hunan Province tall courtyard to extend publicly first 50 include the media outside the condition inside audit card, be unscrambled to be a kind by partial public opinion " a favourable turn " , reason is held to result of careful of this front courtyard bigger expect.
At 8 o'clock half, front courtyard careful is punctual begin, the focus of engage in a battle of both sides dominating debate includes tripartite range, namely whether does teaching plan of Tang Hui service have factual basis, law basis; If need to compensate for, should compensate for with what kind of means, limits, amount; And always first instance of court of state city intermediate people whether fact clear, judgment is legal.
As good as of first instance of He Yongzhou quadrangle, engage in a battle of bilateral counsel for the defence, still be in centrally finally always state city service teachs appoint teach to Tang Hui's fatigue go up whether illegally. Always state city service teachs appoint counsel for the defence thinks, the work that makes to Tang Hui at the outset teachs a decision is lawful limits inside " apparently undeserved " , but do not break the law.
Lawyer of Tang Hui representative thinks, always state city service teachs appoint the illegal sex that to Tang Hui fatigue teachs, administration reconsiders the cancel decision of mechanism, it is the direct basis that administrative action violates.
Always service of director of public security bureau of state city deputy mayor, city, city teachs appoint director Jiang Jianxiang attends front courtyard careful this first. His enumerate of Tang Hui a series of " break the law " behavior, ask for 1.84 million compensation namely, and in always minatory judge waits for hall of city quadrangle put on record.
Listen to his citing, tang Hui appears rage: "Director Jiang of respect did not tell truth, you think to mine consideration talks about a condition, I escape, you want to spend money again bribe I. You want to spend money again bribe I..
Jiang serves as the legal representative of appellee, when making final statement, say: "We are special to appellant daughter the circumstance considers not, humanitarian care is inadequate, express regret here. Express regret here..
This is Tang Hui after fatigue teachs incident happening, always state city service teachs appoint express regret first. Back-to-back, jiang Jianxiang says, this case causes attention, because interweaving among them,be the contradiction of too much affection, manage, law. To apologetic compensation of Tang Hui, at affection at manage it is appropriate, but at the law character, law is not trifling matter.
Jiang Jianxiang says, tang Hui breaks the law for many times appeal for help, always substation of public security of 0 hill area has state city 3 times to report to him have work education to Tang Hui, he is with education admonitory means is handled, final Tang Hui " do not listen to help sb to get over his worries, refuse to mend one's ways despite of repeated admonition " , just make lawfully the decision that fatigue teachs.
Always state city service teachs appoint during the speech, tang Hui for a time rage, be about to send argue barge.
Clearance of front courtyard careful, when Jiang Jianxiang accepts our newspaper reporter to interview, reiterate again, tang Hui appeals for help for many times, had affected someone else. "My located to the thing of her daughter and her condition, sympathize with very much and understand, but she adopts the irregularity with dead make a stand against to appeal for help means. " Jiang Jianxiang says, menorth face shirtschanism of our public security has the responsibility that maintains security of society and stability. "I sign, also do not have method. " he complements.
100 thousand " grant-in-aid " contend for
In careful of 4 hours front courtyarthe best selling modern dining chairsd, in always state city service teachs appoint desire " to Tang Hui 100 thousand yuan " on the thing, bilateral engage in a battwatch casesle is most intense.
According to Tang Hui one party says, arrived 31 days on May 29 this year, service of He Yongzhou city teachs Hunan Province tall courtyard appoint, active Xiang the most popular selling norton internet antivirusTanghui puts forward front courtyard transfer to other localities to solve, satisfy 3 requirements that Tang Hui appeals, ask administration is compensated for namely, include written apology, reach the compensation that violates person freedom 1463.85 yuan, spirit damages solatium 1000 yuan.
Always state city service teachs appoint, still put forward " to Tang Hui 100 thousand yuan " , want her to put forward to nolle prosequi only. On the front courtyard careful July 2, lawyer of Tang Hui representative puts forward 100 thousand yuan of compensation to say. Always state city service teachs appoint spokesman Luo Gongjun denies at once: "It is lawful that we think to teach to Tang Hui's fatigue, nonexistent compensation, just be what do not increase her to appeal to tired, considering the problem of her economy respect, we coordinate local government, give her certain relief. Give her certain relief..
Tang Hui's lawyer expresses: "Always state city service teachs appoint be willing to advance to be mediated all right in 2 careful, if Tang Hui nolles prosequi, give Tang Hui 100 thousand, but this money goes from where, this specification always state city service teachs appoint think oneself are wrong. This specification always state city service teachs appoint think oneself are wrong..
Through 4 hours in the morning front courtyard careful, media, bailiff and the person that share in a school class, the house repast that all is on the side of trial law court, wait to adjudge a result afternoon. Final, hunan Province tall courtyard announces choose period is adjudged.
After front courtyard careful adjudges an end, tang Hui walks out of a court, focusing of tens of domestic media watch for an opportunity. Right now Tang Hui, expression is quiet.
Before 3the best selling watch cases months, always city quadrangle announces Tang Hui to lose a lawsuit, when she walks out of a court, crouch in the cry bitterly on the ground, when Tang Hui accepts our newspaper reporter to interview, express " should continue to appeal for help " , "Have freedom, but without fair justice " .
Right now, quiet Tang Hui, tell a reporter again: "If tall courtyardnorton internet antivirus cannot give me a judicial court decision, I appeal for help to Beijing even, with always state city service teachs appoint thought illegal means. With always state city serviwatch case manufacturerce teachs appoint thought illegal means..
And going up when careful of the middle of forhead, its representative lawyer expresses, already had communicated with Tang Hui, "No matter be,win, tang Hui does not want to appeal for help again, do not take the issue beyond law " . The representative crosses 3 lawyers of Tang Hui the most popular watch casescase, when accepting our newspaper reporter to interview, ever all expressed, hope Tang Hui does not appeal for help again, take normal law course, answer the life of normal person too. harrison hot spring public pool
Always after careful of state law court ends, make Tang Hui very nervous, it is its openly photograph ascended each big paper, the face did not make the video of mosaic, also went up CCTV. "Go visitting a daughter every time, I plunge into the hair rise, wear very well go seeing her. Never be recognized. " Tang Hui smile says.
No comments:
Post a Comment